Never the Twain Shall Meet? Integrating Chinese and Western Management research
نویسنده
چکیده
This commentary offers several directions for the development of Chinese management research based on the penetrating analyses provided by Barney and Zhang (2009) and Whetten (2009). First and foremost, Chinese management researchers can develop novel, seminal ideas and theories that are not necessarily tied to the Chinese cultural context but are applicable in diverse cultural contexts. The success of this approach depends on the merit of the ideas and theories proposed. A fusion, or combined emic-etic approach, can also be attempted, which integrates elements from Western and indigenous theories. Finally, the synergistic approach involves a dynamic interplay of Chinese and Western management research, which will eventually lead to innovative, culture-general theories. This article argues that all three approaches should be emphasized in Chinese management research.
منابع مشابه
East and West: Ancient Wisdom and Modern Science*
In modern times, science and technology have become dominant forces in the world, and Western civilization with its pioneering role in technological development is commonly seen as a symbol of progress and enlightenment. This has been associated with a strong tendency to glorify progress and evolution and to look down upon the past as a time of infancy and immaturity. It has also been repeatedl...
متن کاملNow the Twain Shall Meet: Combining Social Sciences and Software Engineering to Support Development of Emergent Systems
متن کامل
A Researcher’s Dilemma - Philosophical and Methodological Pluralism
In many research textbooks the distinction between qualitative and quantitative research is inadvertently linked with philosophical perspectives. This in essence creates a mutually exclusive relationship between method and philosophy. Initially researchers are led to believe, from these textbooks, that research is neatly divided into mutually exclusive categories, these being quantitative and q...
متن کاملIf Ever the Twain Shall Meet: Graph Theoretical Dimensions of Formal and Informal Organization Structure
Formal and informal organization structure have been described as “opposing poles of a duality”—one which has yet to be fully resolved. The aim of this paper is to detail an approach to treating both structures in a comparable way, an approach that explicitly recognizes core and underlying commonalties. Two distinct analytical strategies are employed to this end. The first involves a detailed c...
متن کامل